ࡱ> y Rbjbj?b{{GD(@h08 tfvR"R"R"bedededededede$gGj>eQ'^!R"''eDe}7}7}7'be}7'be}7}7F|lTGpus/`FNee0fG~j3j$GGjGR",~#}7T$%R"R"R"ee5R"R"R"f''''jR"R"R"R"R"R"R"R"R", : TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R R ez h( ς]'Yf[ sePlf[b _lς ς] 215006 Xd lWg>yOvy^Bl BlRes gvL?eN㉳Q:g6R [BlbU\~~㉳QvSzz0 SbLOSFU0I{6R^(WQvTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R eQYTN~~S_NNvQ(WBl SV^NsNL?el NvT\OltR /fNySLv6R^ b0TaW~~㉳Q:g6R}wnNlN~~㉳QWKN-N FO[v^^NNL?eN㉳Q;mRv|Q[0NSN;NSO0Tab_b z^0OSHeRI{ebU\_6R^ SNnxOTaWL?eN㉳QЏLvTl'`N[He'`0TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6RHTsQN~qQuvsQ| [NKNvvNzN gRNcGSL?eN㉳QvteSOT(0 sQ.͋L?eN㉳QTaLOSFUT\Olt N0_㉳QL?eNvSNy` S_MR bVckYN>yOlWg04O@wopv>yO~gSN)RvsQ|͑~ L?e:gsQNv[NKNA~Su@wL?eN ُ(WW0W_6e0?bK\b0>yOO0sXObI{Whs_$\:NzQ0NNWav/f L?e YNL?eɋُ$Nyg;Nv~~㉳Q:g6Rv^l gR[S%cQ^ gvR0vQTg/f YS,gSN~1u N$Ny~~㉳Q:g6R_0Rm㉄vL?eNHhNleQ0RO nSKN-N L?eNv㉳QVdkHTsQ'YO0\ YT\ɋvyOvT3z[gbN%N͑Z0 WN2clWg>yOΘiv BlbN[Us gv~~㉳Q:g6R \L?eN_[0Rt'`Sv nSKN-NRN㉳Q0[dk Ny`/f ۏNek[UsLvL?e YTL?eɋ6R^ NO Yُ$Ny~~㉳Q:g6Rv^ gR0ZfяzlRR[bv 0L?eɋl 0O9eNSck(Wxb-Nv 0L?e Yl 0O9e O/f/{_Ndky`0(WN (WS_MRvSlSO6RsX*g9h,g9e‰v̀of N ُyՋVǏ[zlvb/g'`Ock [BlibU\~~㉳QRvRR&TS_bR /fX[(W%N͑uv0(W,g!k 0L?eɋl 0vO9eǏ z-N zQRuYec1\f[dkyۏhǏ(u v bN~ gNo}Yv L?eɋl FOYgN1uN*NCgZ'`TlQO^cяNvlb|~eggbL [؏ gaINT 0L?eɋl 0v bwv N/f 0L?eɋl 0v0 [1]49 vQ[ dN N`KNY ؏X[(W@wSNybU\L?eN㉳Qzzvۏ 1\/f(WL?eɋNL?e Y6R^KNYSJ_ ~b[㉳QL?eNvfN'`el0NVYllSV[v[eg w TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6ROnbo@wُy҉rNR0 FOS‰bVL?elf[Lu [NTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RvsQltS/f%N͑ Nv0[N~'YRf[ NN[NL?eN㉳QVofv`a /fN$N [b0,{ Ne\OQQ[vQ[W:g6R:NSWgQ{wegv0v^0W NN_v-NvL?eN㉳Q:g6R 1\bP(WNL?eɋ0L?e YTOُ Ny nSKN-N0(W{vh"}VQ N g\pef[NVl:NwƋ̀of (WL?el NvfN'`~~㉳Q:g6Rv;N N [TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R\ONRek_NTc0[2]67-76[3]28-35 FO/f L?el NvfN'`~~㉳Q:g6R/fNyƖT'`i_ vQ-NQ+T@wTy'`(_v~~㉳Q:g6R0\TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNvQNL?el NvfN'`~~㉳Q:g6RۏLNv^ elSOsQ:g6RvQ(Wub;N6R^yr'`0 ďN:Nbk bVf[Lu[NTaW~~㉳Q:g6Rvc ؏W,g\PYuNylWKN-N0L?elf[Lu[NTaW~~㉳Q:g6RvƋ ;`SO N؏OVNlNlf[LuTl>yOf[LuvwƋO~06q NCg)RR v'`(0S_NNKNvRϑ[krQ0)R[sQ|NvR^V0NlQqQ)RvvsQT'` z^I{ebeg w L?eNNlN~~GWX[(W@w>fWv]_0ُQ[NylW-Nv~~㉳Qt Nvcy0RL?eNWKN-NRN(u0[NTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R _{~TL?eN㉳Qvyrk'`(\OQN蕢c0 gtNdk ,ge\[TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6Rvi_06R^bV0@bb4Nvtx06R^Fhg0NQ[W:g6RKNvsQ|I{ۏL NgY:NbU\lWgL?eN㉳QvzzcOSNy`0 N0TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RvLu[ (W~~㉳Qt N e,gf[ho][ĖYec cgqS㉉Ne_v N T \~~㉳Q:g6RRR:NTaWNQ[W$NyW,g{|W0MR/fǏS_NNKNbTave_eg㉳Q~~ OSFUN㉿O/fvQOTR/fOnc,{ Ne\OQv g~_gRvQ[eg~~~N N0Sl[$R^\KN0[4]10-18 (Wlf[-N _NX[(W@w{|yO-N㉳Q~~v$Nyt`{|W0 wQSO0RL?eN㉳QWKN-N 1\v^0WX[(WTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6Rُ$N{|~~㉳Q:g6R0@b TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R /fcL?e:gsQNL?ev[NKNǏ|_dkbTave_egSL?eNvNy~~㉳Qe_0[NُNi_v+TIN SNN N$N*NebRNbc vQN [ǏS_NNKNbTave_eg㉳Q~N0ُ̑v Ta /f[~~㉳Qv~g v sSS_NN[Ng~bvL?eN㉳QeHhwQ g݋CgTc6RR0(WُNaIN N [N\~~㉳Q~gN~,{ NeRNev~~㉳Q:g6R OYL?eɋ0L?e Y0L?eQ0N0OYtNS3uɋYtI{ 1\ N(WTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RKNR0ُN\L?eNN~,{ Neev:g6R ^ReQ0RQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6RvtuKN-N0 vQN TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNL?eN:NYt[a0@b L?eN /fcNL?e:gsQ:NNeS_NNvlQlN0Vdk L?e:gsQ[lN~~v;mR 1\ N^\NTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R0[Ndk{|L?e;mR yKN:NlN~~vL?eYt:g6Rf:NAQS_0 NY^ N w TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R;NS+TN N Ny6R^b_` 1. LOSFU0LOSFU/fcS_NNLǏvcv[݋Tleg㉳QL?eNvNy6R^0 cQv/f LOSFU;mR-NvS_NNv^^[hQ NPRNvQN;NSOv/ecN.^R0vS S_NNSN[Bl_^SvQN;NSO(Wnc6eƖ0l_wƋT{I{ebv.^R0FONЏ\O~g Neg w ُN.^R/f gRNL?eN-NvNeS_NNv ^\Nyr[NeS_NNvRN v^ NP Ne@bv㉺Nb-Nzċ0OXT7hE\N-Nz0WMO0LOSFUv_U\ NS_NNKNwQ g[݋va?a:NMRc v^NL?eNNyv^ N YBg:NP0 2. 0/f(W-Nz,{ NNvE\T N S_NNKNǏbTave_㉳Q~~vNy6R^0(WS_NN:ONlva?a b(WLOSFU㉳QǏ z-NmGP@\ b1uNL?eNNyASR YBgV S_NNeRLS㉄v`Q N 1\_eQ-Nz,{ NN S%cvQ(W~~㉳Q z^;Nc0Oo`NAmOb0T㉹eHhcI{ebvE\\O(u NOOS_NNKNb㉳QL?eNvOS0 3. ,{ Neċ0O0,{ Neċ0O/fcS_NN\L?eNcN~wQYNNwƋvċ0OXT 1uċ0OXT[HhNۏeQ0RL?e Y0L?eɋI{Q[W:g6RvMRofTS~gۏLKmvNy6R^0vMR(WbV ,{ Neċ0O:g6R؏\PYuNlFUN~~WKN-N  \*gck__eQ0RL?eN㉳QWKN-N0 (WWYV[eg w (WL?eN㉳QWnfMX[(W@wYeg-Nzċ0Oearly neutral evaluation [7]1-3 0\W[$Rminitrial [8]199 0 NwQ g~_gRvNnonbinding arbitration [9]172-175 I{hsb__v,{ Neċ0O:g6R0,{ Neċ0O:g6RwQ gMNOS_NN NR[Ev~~㉳Qg0feONNVR_0R[݋ nS Negv\O(u0 N06R^vtQwSvQbV N TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R(WNLuVQvtQw (WbVv~~㉳QSO|-N TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6Rcknbo@wev͑v0WMO02006t^ -NqQ-N.YRlQSTVRbRlQSTTS^N 0sQN2TSL?eN0ePhQL?eN㉳Q:g6Rva 0 cQg^Sb[L?eNv(WQvYCQS~~㉳Q:g6R02007t^Ǐv 0SWel 0[L?egblT6R^vĉ[ NS Tt^ 0L?e Yl[eagO 0[L?e YTN㉄vĉ[ 1\/fُyl?eV{c[ NvzlNir02014t^O9eTv 0L?eɋl 0_NN9eel-Nybk㉄vag>k ĉ[(WL?eTP0L?eePNSL?e:gsQLOl[ϑCgvHhN-NSN(u0 (WdkKNMR L?eɋ-NS_NNKNǏLOSFUb㉳QvHhNpeϑ N[ N]`Snc^8^ؚvkO02009t^ hQVlbN[L?eɋHhNTTdɋvks:N35.9%0[10]5 0RN2011t^ ُNpencf/feGS0RN48%0[11]5 NklƉΑ N w -NVv N6R^[v^^d[O0(WV 1990t^Ǐv^~1996t^O9ev 0L?eN㉳Ql 0Administrative Dispute Resolution Act nxzNSb0\P0\W[$RI{(WQvYyTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R0 N[ N 20N~70t^Nw TsOr0kSuTlQO gRI{:gsQO]ՋpЏ(uTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R0[12]17-18[13]98-101 (WVvSl[gW-N NN~90t^NRS_NNKNǏbTۏ 3udɋ~Hh N[ N]/fNy8^`SvL?eN㉳Qe_0[14]228 (W2001t^v \Hh -N Nɋlbvl\+Yl[Lord Woolf (W$RQ-NfnxcQ lNHhN-NBll[=\S_[S_NNǑSfN'`~~㉳Q:g6Rv|^y T7h(uNlQlNHhN [15]803 N :NL?eNS_NNǏTae_S㉠~~kbdNx0 2002t^3g4ewuHev 0Sl[gɋMR[fN 0Pre-action Protocol for Judicial Review ۏNekĉ[ SJT(WcwSl[gMR _{NJTvNNbca vQvv(WNOOSeOSFU㉳Q~~ MQHhNۏeQSl[g z^0(W_V0bVS~n0W:SI{0W T7hHTsQЏ(uTaW:g6RSL?eNvR0[16]252-253[17]12-13 fQTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNyl NvTaW:g6Rv:S+R0Vdk _{~TL?eNvyrp [TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNuvỲofۏLRg0 (WsNL?e;mR-N @wL?eNRvevA~͑Te YBgS L?e:gsQNNO`USe'`0ؚCg'`v }TN gN Kbk]>f_N:N~0:NN[bL?eNR L?e:gsQnfM0WNL?ev[N_U\@wT\O0VS_NL?elf[_̑fJody Freeman Yec1\cQ yN;NSOckmm0WNeQ0R{6R0cO gR0?eV{N[eS_-N0 [19]323lQyT\OltvQs 9eSNL?e:gsQ:NUSN-N_vL?eNR[s~g S NKNv /fSU\QNyOSFUT\OsQ| :_L?e:gsQNyeS_NNKNǏl0[݋ OSR[bL?eNR0TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6Rck/f(W N6R^Sv'Ỳof Nubv0(W N\VYf[ weg [vtQw [E N/flQqQL?eW-NvT\OltR(W~~㉳QWُN+gzv6q^8O0[20]266-267[21]310-311 wQSO TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNN N$N*Neb QYTNL?el NvlQyT\OR ,{N TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RSNQL?e:gsQNL?ev[NKNv[b0(WL?eNSuKNE S_NNKN]6qX[(W@wN[ z^v[z0t`v~~㉳Q:g6R ^S_RNmdُy[zrQ O>yOy^VR_0Rs^Tr`0NNWav/f 1uNǑSNzN'`v z^g Q[WL?eN㉳Q:g6R^FO NTُy[zrQ S \ُy[zr`lQ_S0\S0:NNQ[\OQN/ec,geve S_NNGW\|R>e0RYUOS܀N[eNO gQ[KN N ~~㉳Q;mR_NVdkl:NNNy^sSbv T 8nb0Ndk N T TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R1uN\~~㉳QvQ[Cg؏R_~NS_NN :Nb~~v㉳Q L?e:gsQNL?ev[NKNKN_{>e_[b'`Y` ǏlN[݋ BlSevNN0ُ1\SNKQ gQ[W:g6R[b'` gYO [݋'` Nv:w :NO YS_NNKNv[zr`cO6R^ NvQY:g0 ,{N TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R gRNWL?e:gsQNL?ev[Nvlt'` ۏ ͑QX [l sQ|0S_MR S_NN(WSuL?eNKNE NۏLt'`vl S R>e lb vsaASRnfM0vQ[ 1\l_6R^vzRw vQa(W:NSN;NSOKNvlcONy/ec'`Fhg0 [NUOl_t vQ&qp_{/fNvNRTl N/f*NSObl_|~,g0 [22]18 MRZPltSNɋQ[W:g6RSNS_NNKNvl ُe_N,g+gPn0TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6Rv[eQ ǏgL?ev[NNL?e:gsQKNۏLl0[݋vehh SNKQ gdkyAm _0Neb [SNWt'`v0UNlvlQlTf6q/fNQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6R:NSWU\_v V:NL?e Y0L?eɋI{Q[W:g6R/fPRNL?eL:NvTl'`ُNċ$R:\^egSL?eNv0FO/f Tl'`ċ$Rv^ N/f㉳QL?eNv/UN_ _N~^gsOve_0S_l_ǏNnT0PS elnS_NNvQ(WBlKNe ُyPRNTl'`ċ$RegSL?eNve_OO>f:yQIc_KNY0NQ[W:g6R N Tv/f TaW:g6R~ǏNTl'`ċ$RُNce_ _vۏeQ0RNTl'`Nu9hnvW@x'`L?eNKN N0[ǏS_NNKNvleg BlL?eNv[('`㉳Q0Vdk sSO(WL?eL:N NX[(WTl'`Nv`Q N S_NNKN_NSN(W NݏSl_vybk'`ĉ[vMRc N [BlfwQR '`0ScSvN㉳QeHh ُ1\:y@wTa㉳QL?eNvSzz0NQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6R:N;Rgeg&T[TaW:g6RvOSFUzz NMQ gJRe\KN^0 N SeRϑ[kNb_bTavS'` (u:N 1uNL?ev[NNL?e:gsQKNv0WMON[ Nv^ Ns^I{ sSO(WSuL?eNKNEۏLl L?e:gsQ_NO)R(uvQ(WwƋ0Oo`TDnI{ebvOR0WMO [YN1_R0WMOvL?ev[NNeeRSR OvQcSNvQ N)RvOS0ُ/ff[N(uTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R[He'`v;Nt1u0 FO/f L?e:gsQNL?ev[NKNv Ns^I{r` NN/fNy;`SO Nvc v^ N_6qNh(WwQSON-NS_NNKNvw[Rϑ[ksQ|0L?ev[Nv^^/flQCgRvmg\O(u[aTR gN vS \O:Nt'`v;NSO NN__OU(us[sX-NvTyDnS9eSُy Ns^I{r`0HQ (WS_MR@bYvOo`SeN N L?ev[NNeSNPRb~0Q~S^I{e_ \HhNf2NlQOƉΑKN-N N )R(u>yOlQO T`1_Re0av`:_RvlQCgR蕄vN,_t [Bl>yO[,gez:WTɋBlv/ec0vQ!k ck_QeNm nSvX[(W _N/fL?ev[NKQ gꁫ N)R0WMO ۏ TL?e:gsQNeNS_navTa~gv gRy{x0$\vQ/fQ0RvMRbV_Y0We[LNL?e Y0L?eɋ%ɋvsQTvR'`8h6R^ f gRN~ckv[Nvُy N)R0WMO0gT (W-Nz,{ NNNeQ~~㉳QǏ zv`b_ N ǏS%c-Nz,{ NN[NTaۏ zvc6RCg _N gRN[L?eNS_NNKNv Ns^ar`ۏLN[ z^v~OP0Qdkyy GW9eS@wL?e:gsQNv[NKNvRϑ[ksQ| _N:y@wǏTae_b~gvS'`0 vQ[ S_NNKNRϑ[krQv1Ya v^ N_6qgbbTavx0V:NsSO(WlN~~W ~~S_NNKN_Nv^^[hQRGWRLe0(WRRN0m9CgvObI{HhN-N S_b[cc@w]'YDnvǖ;Nb'YONKNe S_NNKN T7hX[(W@wRϑ[k1Yav`Q FOُv^ NYx~~S_NNЏ(uTaW:g6R㉳Q~~0N9h,g N `[s~~S_NNRϑ[kv[hQRGWRLe /f NR[Ev Ta^g;mR(W^GWavRϑ[kagN NU\_S_^\8^`0S~~S_NNEQRccꁫvORKNY SNSnavOSFU~g 1\:N4xdTabKNxcOS0ckY gf[@bcQv _U\SS gbHevN N8^:Nv_{HQ Rϑs^a r`vpKN yOlQO[NL?eN㉳Q;mRvlQvsQR v^1udkPfNTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R\O:NNyS_NN,gMOv~~㉳Q:g6Rv8h_yr_0 Te :NnxOTaW:g6Rvz)RЏL ؏8T~ N;NSO N/fNL?eN g)R[sQ|v,{ NNvSN0Nyl~~ N T L?eN8^8^urm0R,{ NNv)Rv0:N2bkTa㉳QL?eNv;mRO[,{ NNv)Rv ^S_w g)R[sQ|v,{ NNSN0RTa;mRKN-N OvQ_hav:gO0ُSNEQ[TaW:g6RЏLvOo`W@x TeMQV)R[sQ|N:ONSN (WNTcQ_ qSSg~bvOSv3z['`0 N/f_^vOSR0L?eNNy__mS YBgvl_0(Wdk̀of N [Bl_^NeQTa㉳QL?eNvǏ z [NSeS_NNegGW gvY0[NL?ev[Neg _^vOSRe gHeKQ gvQvkNL?e:gsQ(WNNwƋ NvRR SMNOv[N[N~~㉳Q~gv NTtgg0[NL?e:gsQeg _^vSeNeQ Yc:yvQlaL?e;mR-N@bX[(WvSUtu RgwSeQɋvSΘi NfeOvQSN0RTa;mRKN-N0ُ7h 1\SN)QS_NNKNvTa?l g~ObTOSvb0 N/f-Nz,{ NNvE\;Nc0HQcQv/f v^^@b gvTaWL?eN㉳Q;mRGW-Nz,{ NNvSN (Wُeb LOSFU;mRO/ff0FO(W[-N S_NN(WNSuKNE?aavcۏL[݋v`b_v^ N8^0V:NN$R_t N w NeNeS_NN;NRcۏLT \O[e:NvQtN0:y1_vhs0[28]321-323 Vdk S_NN__ N?aaQT[ecۏLT㉄v,{Nek0:NSb4x NЏ(uTaW~~㉳Q:g6RvP@\ _eQ-Nz,{ NN S%cvQ(WS_NNKNvz_~R0 Te YMR@b -Nz,{ NNvNeQ ǏS%cvQ z^;N[Cg Y~OPS_NNKNRϑv Ns^a'` v^nxO\ g)R[sQ|v,{ NNSN0ROSFUǏ zKN-N0S_6q -Nz,{ NNv҉rSN9hnc~~㉳Qv[Eup;mS%c vQ"$&,026>ʴճհ侱 ͽͽ﨓ܱܱܰht{5CJOJPJo(h\>h g5CJOJPJo(h\>hv5CJOJPJo(h[h gCJOJPJo((h+h gB*CJOJQJaJo(ph(h+hOB*CJOJQJaJo(phh+h4}pCJOJQJaJo(h+h gCJOJQJaJo("h+h g5CJOJQJaJo(h+hOCJOJQJaJo(> @ H  6 : D F J N T Z \ b d f j p r t v | ῵ח|uu|k\jhm#hI0JUaJhm#h0aJo( h{?NaJo( h<'aJo(hm#hvaJo(hm#hm#aJo(hm#hIaJo(hm#hB aJo(hm#h7&#aJo(hm#hfeaJo( hi$ZaJo(hm#hxaJo( hxaJo(hm#h&EOaJo(hm#haJo(hm#h~5aJo(hm#h1 aJo($|  $ , . 2 @ b f h j n 롗|Зu h<'aJo(hm#h-paJo( hTkaJo(hm#hfeaJo(hm#haJo( hf1gaJo(hm#hcaJo(hm#h?baJo(hm#hR?;aJo(hm#hgaJo(hm#h`aJo( hw#aJo(hm#hIaJo(hm#h&EOaJo(hm#hB aJo(, BFNRX\lpxz~,bdfprtzɳveVO hxaJo(h{?NhB*aJo(ph hIh5VB*CJaJo(phhIhXB*H*aJo(phh{?Nh< B*aJo(phh{?Nh{?NB*aJo(phh{?Nh-pB*aJo(phh{?NhgB*aJo(ph h{?NaJo(hm#hgaJo( hf1gaJo(hm#h5VaJo(hm#hcaJo(hm#haJo( hnSaJo(z|~DJLNPfи䱪ڛ~wmwmwchm#h aJo(hm#h-|aJo( h-|aJo(hw#B*aJo(ph jhw#0JB*UaJphh\| hA*TB*aJo(ph hofaJo( h aJo(hm#hm#aJo( h<'aJo( hTkaJo(hm#h5VaJo(hm#haJo(hm#hA*TaJo( hP8aJo(hm#h}taJo(#,4JT\^vJNPR Zlvx|~|un h B$aJo( h~waJo( h aJo( hofaJo(hZh~oaJo( h*k3aJo(hZh-|aJo(hIH*aJo(hIhIH*aJo( h-|aJo(hm#h-|aJo( h~oaJo( h?LhaJo( hR@aJo( hTkaJo(hm#h aJo(hm#h B*aJo(ph)~  DLTvz  uiZhm#hIB*aJo(phh~wB*aJo(phh B$h B$B*aJo(phhY2B*aJo(phh B$hofB*aJo(phhm#hofaJo( hofaJo( h B$aJo(hm#haJo(hm#hIaJo( hTkaJo( h aJo( h~waJo( hi_aJo(hm#h aJo(h B$h B*aJo(ph"$(.PRlrtTV\jz|ó{tmcWWMhm#hmaJo(hIhIH*aJo(hm#hk@OaJo( hw aJo( h~waJo(hm#haJo(hm#haJo(hm#hCRaJo(hm#hc aJo(h\>h5q5CJOJPJo(h\>h}t5CJOJPJo(hm#haJo(hm#h}tB*aJo(phhERB*aJo(phh B$B*aJo(phhxB*aJo(ph&,0H`pvx"(,4׼׼õëÝבsdXhB*aJo(phhm#hB*aJo(phhm#hvB*aJo(phhm#h%HB*aJo(phhNB*aJo(ph haJo( hYaJo(hm#hIRaJo( h B$aJo( haJo(hm#hCRaJo(hm#hvaJo(hm#hR?;aJo(hm#h}taJo(hm#hc aJo(hm#hmaJo(46.04JNPTV^`blx⬝Ǒyyoh^Thm#hfkaJo(hm#hjzaJo( hNaJo(hm#hR?;aJo(hJsB*aJo(phhYB*aJo(phh{B*aJo(phhm#hjzB*aJo(phh B*aJo(phhm#hvB*aJo(phhm#hfkB*aJo(phhB*aJo(phhm#h%HB*aJo(phhm#hIRB*aJo(ph  *TXdl "$2>̷̢̛̰̔{to hzwo( hzwaJo(jhm#h80JUaJhm#h8aJo( haJo( hniaJo( h aJo( hNaJo( haJo( hriaJo( hR?;aJo( haJo(hm#hIRaJo( h aJo( h B$aJo( h{aJo(hm#hfkaJo(hm#hjzaJo()>@BHFx .26JN` frĽ颛Ģznh)h)H*aJo(jh`10JUaJ h`1aJo( h&vlaJo( h paJo( hNaJo(hm#h~aJo(hm#hIRaJo( haJo( h aJo( h{aJo(hdWhNB*aJo(phh&mThB*aJo(ph haJo( hzwo( ho( h{o(+p #(((,*0^0j1f4@7r::P=t=@>@CCDdH$88@&XDdYDda$gdL@`gdL@rt P T n p t z *!2!f!!!!!":"Ͽzpi_pPzzph|5hB1aB*aJo(phh/n h #FaJo( h #FaJo(hm#h\2aJo( hB1aaJo( hf1gaJo( h\2aJo(hh 5OJQJaJo(h\>hER5CJOJPJo(h\>hR/V5CJOJPJo(h\>h\25CJOJPJo( h aJo( h paJo( h aJo(h)h)H*aJo( h`1aJo(h)H*aJo(:"^"r"t"""""""# # ##J#V#`#b##########$$$$$$$$$%&%(%.%0%<%>%@%J%P%v%x%ƽƽٚٚƽxxh_h_aJo( h_aJo( hy7aJo(hm#h&vlaJo( hL@aJo( h*k3aJo( hf1gaJo( heEaJo( h\2aJo(h)H*aJo(h)h)H*aJo( h`1aJo( h&vlaJo( hB1aaJo( h!aJo(hm#h\2aJo( h!aJo(/x%~%%%%%%&&0&B&R&Z&`&h&p&&&&'T''''''' ( (("(*(X(f(h(ϵϣϜϕzsgs]V hy7aJo(h h\2aJo(h0oh0oH*aJo( h aJo(h B*aJo(phhm#h\2B*aJo(ph h`1aJo( h&vlaJo(hm#h\2aJh wH*aJo(h0oh wH*aJo( h waJo( h$KaJo(hm#h\2aJo(hZ2H*aJo(hZ2h)H*aJo(h_h_aJo( h|5aJo(!h(n(p(z(~(((((((((((((((((")&)2)D)P)R)))ںڃ|ungu`YuOh{ -haJo( h!aJo( h,aJo( h{ -aJo( hb iaJo( h8SaJo( h,aJo( h[ aJo(hhu5OJQJaJo(hha5OJQJaJo(hhh:5OJQJaJo(hhR/V5OJQJaJo(hh 5OJQJaJo(hhW$5OJQJaJo( h\2aJo( hW$aJo( hy7aJo()))**0*>*B*R*T*^*h******++X++++ ,@,H,,,,ααΡ΂qj`Y`Y`R`K` hGvaJo( hvaJo( haJo(hhaJo( haJo( h0oh0o0JB*aJo(phh0oh0oB*H*aJphh<'B*OJQJaJo(phh B*OJQJaJo(phhB*OJQJaJo(phh{ -h{ -B*aJph$h{ -h{ -B*OJQJaJo(phh{ -h{ -aJo(h{ -haJo(h{ -h,aJo(,,,,,,--- -P-r-z-~----------------....0.2.\.`.h.n.r........ĺĬĬĥ痂 h}`aJo( h<'aJo( h6aJo( hA aJo( h/~aJo( hNaJo( h~aJo( haaJo(hhaJo( hc.}aJo( h aJo( haJo( hvaJo( h,aJo( he_aJo( h[ aJo(hhR/VaJo(-.......//////(/./4/6T6x6z6666666666>7@7\7b7f777޻»­ɟɟווɟ}Ž}h.h.aJo( h.aJo( h4aJo(hFVhaJo( haJo( hb iaJo( h0aJo( htaJo( hnSaJo( h hWaJo( haJo( h|aJo( ht!aJo(hFVhFVaJo(hFVB*aJo(phhB*aJo(ph-777777777777888"8@8888888888888888888899 9$9.94969:9>9B9F9V9Z9Żůݨݡݨ뚓ςϨ{ hNaJo(hZh/aJo( h)1aJo( h=aJo( h.aJo( h!aJo( h hWaJo(h4h4H*aJo(hq[h37aJo(hq[hq[aJo( h/aJo( hq[aJo( hN aJo( hL aJo(h.h.aJo(h.h4aJo(0Z9z9~9999999999999: ::: :8:::D:F:n:p:r:t:v::::::::ִֻttd] ht{aJo(h\>hc5CJOJPJo(h\>h_5CJOJPJo(h\>h_\S5CJOJPJo(h\>h g5CJOJPJo(h\>h5CJOJPJo( haJo(hNhNaJo(h.h hWaJo( hb iaJo( hNaJo(h.h|k`aJo( h|k`aJo(h.h.aJo( h)1aJo(#::::::::::;;;;;;; ;";$;:;<;>;@;D;H;J;V;X;^;t;|;;;ڸ뮸ڤš¤{qjc{j\j hSI8aJo( h"oaJo( hDKGaJo(h\h\aJo( hi_aJo( h\aJo( hb iaJo(hm#hBaJo(hm#h9aJo(hm#hg)aJo(hm#h((aJo(hm#h:1aJo(hm#hTLaJo( h$KaJo( hvaJo(hm#h7xaJo( ht{aJo(hm#h+faJo(hm#hv'aJo(!;;;;;;;;;;;<<<<&<.<2<:<<<F<J<N<R<Z<l<x<<<<<<<<<<<<<<==="=&=L=N=P=V=ιխ㟘hhJ5OJQJaJo( hhaJo( haJo( hLaJo( hHaJo(jhH0JUaJ h0aJo( h/aJo( hhaJo( h"oaJo( huaJo( hNUaJo( hTaJo( hkaJo( haJo( hmNaJo(0V=j=n=t=z=~=========== >>>>> >$>,>.><>@>F>P>T>h>ɸ¤}tɸjcjYjYjjhm#hA(aJo( hL aJo(hm#h$TaJo(h4H*aJo(h4h4H*aJo(hm#h@aJo(hm#hpS5aJo( hAaJo(hm#hwaJo(hm#h aJo(hm#h=gaJo( h aJo( hTaJo(hhJ5OJQJaJo(hh"m5OJQJaJo(hh: 5OJQJaJo(h>v>>>>>>>>>?2?6?????? @ @@@@@@@@@@@AA䞸yoe[yhm#hcQaJo(hm#hA(aJo(hm#haJo(hm#h|:aJo(hm#h$bAaJo( hJaJo(hAh:?taJo( h m@aJo(h4h4H*aJo( h5"aJo(hVhVaJo( hqaJo(hm#h aJo( hTaJo(hm#hBaJo( h/aJo(hm#hi/aJo(hm#h:?taJo(AAAA*A,A0A2A6A>A@ALANAPA`AfA|AAAAAAAAAAAAAAABB B BBB BƼвڨڔڍ|ڔrrhhm#h.faJo(hm#h8aJo(hm#h7$aJo( h~aJo( hVaJo(hm#h aJo(hm#hcQaJo(hm#h&<aJo(hm#h[aJo(hm#h:?taJo(hm#h|:aJo(hm#hBaJo(hm#h$bAaJo( hL aJo(hm#hi/aJo(hm#hh#(aJo(% B$B0B4B8BaJo(hm#h3aaJo(hm#hmkaJo(hhEg5OJQJaJo(hh: 5OJQJaJo(hhqp5OJQJaJo(hm#hEgaJo( hinaJo( h37aJo(hm#hb.aJo(hm#hh#(aJo(hm#h,aJo(hm#hi/aJo(DDDDDDE4E:E>E@ERE^E`EEEEEEEEE FhFFFFFFFGvGzGGGGG׹{o{e^^ h6aJo(hm#h9~aJo(h9~B*aJo(phhm#h9~B*aJo(phh>B*aJo(ph haJo( hL aJo( h4aJo( h4aJo( h9~aJo(h9~h9~aJo(hm#haJo(hm#hb.aJo(hm#h<aJo(hm#h`aJo(hm#hNaJo(hm#h\aJo($GGHHbHdHjHHHHHHHRI^IhIlIvIIIIIIIVJ^K`KbKpKrKtKɸ®si]Nh6h6B*aJo(phh4h4H*aJo(h6haJo(h6h4B*aJo(ph h>aJo(hm#hh#(aJo(hm#hNaJo( hL aJo(hm#h;paJo(h6h6aJo(hm#h&FiaJo( h6aJo(hm#hReaJo(h9~h9~aJo(hm#h9~aJo( h9~aJo(hm#h6aJo( h$aJo(dHtKKjM PBQfQvQdRSZUfx(XZ$a$gdL@$88@&XDdYDda$gdL@`gdL@ WD`gdL@tKzK~KKKKKKKKKLLLHLLLRLVLLLMLMfMhMxMMMMMаwng`VO h/aJo(hs#Zhs#ZaJo( haJo( hs#ZaJo(h00H*aJo(hhH*aJo( h(_aJo( h>aJo(h|h|aJo( hV~aJo( h|aJo( htaJo(hhP5OJQJaJo(hh: 5OJQJaJo(hh]25OJQJaJo(hhG5OJQJaJo(hh-/5OJQJaJo(MMM4N>NjNpNrNzNNNNNNNNNN4O6OVOZO~OOOOOOOP P6PBPFPJPNPxPPPP"Q(Q>ٲĽ綽٬٥٠Ēĥ\>aJo( hSIaJo( haJo( hTaJo( hs#ZaJo(hs#Zhs#ZaJo( h00aJo(-DQFQJQNQVQXQ\Q`QdQfQlQpQtQvQzQQQQQQQQQpf_fUKD:f:hm#hp}aJo( hr7aJo(hm#haJo(hm#hcaJo( h5aJo(hm#h]aJo(hhB5OJQJaJo(hhw5OJQJaJo(hh5OJQJaJo(hho5OJQJaJo(h\>hF5CJOJPJo(h\>h,w5CJOJPJo(h\>h|o5CJOJPJo(h\>hr75CJOJPJo(h\>h g5CJOJPJo(Q,R8RBRHRLRTRXR`RbRdRhRjRRRRRRRRRSSSSS$S(S.S0S2S:SDSSSSSƼƲƲxnngn hCaJo(hm#hx}yaJo(hm#hJRaJo(hm#hBhaJo( hjaaJo( h-aJo(hm#h[VaJo( haJo( h00aJo(hm#hIaJo(hm#hwaJo(hm#h^4aJo(hm#hX UaJo(hm#hNaJo(hm#hh#(aJo(hm#hp}aJo( hr7aJo($SSSSSTTT T8T:T>T@TBTFTlTrTTTTTTTTUUUUU U&U@UDUVUXUZUƿڵ|rkkdkdkZhm#hSZaJo( h KaJo( hCaJo(hm#hQh0aJo(hm#h_V:aJo(hm#h%aJo(hm#hTaJo(hm#hr\aJo( hjaaJo(hm#h-aJo(hm#h(aJo( huaJo(hm#hpaJo(hm#ho=aJo(hm#h[VaJo(hm#h_|aJo( h-aJo(hm#h:WxaJo(#ZUfUhUtUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUVVVV"V2V:VdVhVjVvVVVVVVVVVVVVƿЮzsll huaJo( h00aJo(hhH*aJo(hm#htaJo(hm#hwiaJo(hm#h\haJo(hm#h(aJo(hm#h aJo( h+aJo( h KaJo(hm#h->aJo(hm#hsOaJo(hm#h:aJo(hm#htiaJo( hERaJo(hm#h'E2aJo(*VVWWWW W"W&W(W2W:WaJo(hm#hitaJo( huaJo(hm#hsgaJo( h+aJo(hm#h,aJo( hg{aJo(hm#h\haJo(hm#hwiaJo( hERaJo(&eSNnbomgv_[ nxOOSFUv z^'`Nyvz)Rcۏ _NSN\O:Nygv ^'`0Wc㉳QL?eNvwQSOeHh0[29]139-140 N Tab_b z^ l_ z^wQ gP6Rc`a0nxOQ[t'`SI{ebv\O(u0[30]15-22 1uNL?eNv㉳Q@bb[v/fL?e:gsQNv[NKNRϑ[k1YavW,g~g @bsQmv/flQqQ)Rv VdkS%c z^:g6R(WP6Rc`a0nxOTa~gt'`Sebv\O(uvBl>f_$\:NR0NVYf[[NTab_b z^v\O:NSgq|  ~TbVv,gW[E {:N TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RvЏL z^SRR:NY N N*N6k 1. $RMRvQY6k06kv;Nvh /fSƖL?eNvTe;NSOSN0RTa;mRKN-N v^:NT~vck_$R;mRZP}YQY]\O0HQ fnxLu[SNTa;mRv;NSO \L?eNS_NNT g)R[sQ|v,{ NN8T~0RTa;mRKN-N0YgvQ-NNe;NSONpeOYv ^S_c QNhN0:N2(WTaۏ z-NSQsvP@\ Te;NSOg}Y؏^qQ T [e)R[sQ|v-Nz,{ NN;Nc$R;mR0vQ!k 6R[Ta;mRv z 1\bvSvQOMO!k^bRekqQƋ Te[Ta;mRvw0SĉR0U_0O[ĉRI{ z^'`Ny\OQ~[0gT _U\TTN[gjoint fact-finding ;mR qQ T[L?eN-NvsQ.'`N[ۏLdƖTRg NOb_bN*N:NTe;NSO@b TvN[W@x0 2. ck_v$R6k0ُN6ke(WǏN;NSOKNvxFU bTe;NSOGWcSv㉳QeHh0\O:NMRc TeSNNHQ^S_Rd_/f^[I{ba'`z:W l HfvQwQSOv)RvsQR0T OۏeQ0RwQSOvTa^gs0(WdkǏ z-N SNeSN Ne0WT[ecQՋc'`v㉳QeHh0Te;NSO_NSN(WN_Y1\3uf]v^~ \O:NOSFU;mRvRYLu0(WTeS_NNKN:ONvcla?av`Q N ؏SNBl-Nz,{ NN S%cvQ(WTeS_NNKNvegVzh\O(u0(WdkW@xKN N ǏYVTvS YOSFU0YOS Ne͑eteLu vb_bwQ gqQƋ'`v㉳QeHh v^g~~{rfNbvTOS0 3. OSve\L6k0(WTee\LOSvǏ z-N SNc[N蕄vNXT[OSv=[`QU\_vcw0YgSu`RSfb~[v`b_ el~~e\LS gOSv ؏SN/TR͑eOSFUۏ z0  N OSvHeR L?e:gsQNv[N1\L?eNv㉳Q@bgT~{rvOS (W'`( N^\NlQlT T0[NُNOSvHeR ^S_:SR N$Ny`b_ۏLR+Rc vQN YgOS/f~1uLOSFU z^bv b/f(WlbNYv-Nz,{ NNvE\;Nc N[bv ROSNwQ gT T Nv~_gR0YgS_NN[OS g_v SNTlbcwɋ BllbdOSb[JTOSeHe0:Ne:_OSvHeR SNQPtbVlNWvZPl (WL?eN㉳QW_N_eQTOSvSlnx6R^0 (WwQSOv6R^ N 3unxTOS {NS_NNvN Ta:NMRc0NllbStnx3uT SN cgq{f z^[TOSۏL[g0&{TSlnxagNv Nllb^\OQnxQ[fN0(W\OQnxQ[T NeS_NNb~e\LTOSv [eS_NNSTlb3u:_6RgbL0 vQN YgTa;mR/f(Wlbv;Nc N[bv @bbvOSR^S_wQ gNSl$RQv TvHeR0ُ/fV:N lb(W;NcL?eN㉳QvǏ z-N ]~bbwN[OSTl'`v[gL# V @bbvOS^S_Nlb\OQv$RQwQ g TI{HeR0(WbV 2014t^Ov 0L?eɋl 0,{95agĉ[ L?efNN$RQ0[wQ g TI{HeR SN\O:NgbL TIN0(W{ weg ُNĉ[}vkNelwQ gۏekKNY FON6q/fX[(W:wv0(W‰_ N :SROSNfNُ$N*Ni_ MR/fL?eNS_NN(W-Nz,{ NNv;Nc N@bbvT㉹eHh TR/flb(W[OSۏL[gvW@x N[OSHeRvNy[eS0lb\OQvfNV6qSNۏL:_6RgbL FO\O:NgbL TINvtSv^ NPNfN0[Nl[\O:N-Nz,{ NN;Nc NbvTOS 1uNl[(WOSbvǏ z-N_Nw0RNTl'`[gvL# V _N^S_bvQ\O:NgbL TINvHeR0[Ndk{|OS _NeQSL[Bllb6R\OL?efNe:_vQHeR0YgNeS_NN(WOSuHeT Ne\LOSv [eSNTlb3u:_6RgbL0 mQ0NQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6RvsQ| Rgdk bNSN wQ TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R/fN{|NQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6R6qv_v~~㉳Q:g6R0$Nv]_KNY SN(u NhRN;`~0 h1 $N{|L?eN㉳Q:g6RKNv]_ Q[WL?eN㉳Q:g6RTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R6R^b_`L?eɋ0L?e Y0N0OYt03uɋYtI{LOSFU00,{ Neċ0OI{~~㉳QCgRR_^\Q[~~S_NN~~㉳QĉRegnzlvUST^O~NS_NN;NR:N;NS_NNKNvsQ|[bT\O z^,g(Cg)R[T)Rv[TЏLǏ z z_S0lQ_Sup;m'`0y['` 6q N]_vX[(W v^ NasT@wTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6R1\/f$N{|*b6q[zv~~㉳Q:g6R0N[ N (WNVvL?eN㉳QSO|-N $NYNN~qQuvsQ|Q~KN-N0ُwQSOhs(WY N$N*Neb vQN Nzz~g N w TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6R/fvNN~(WNwv0ُ(WDNQ[:gsQvTaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RYL?e Y0L?eɋ -Nhs_$\:Nf>f0(Wُy`b_-N TaW:g6RvL]NQ[W:g6RKN-N(WQ[W:g6RvЏ\OǏ z-N Q[:gsQ gCg^S_NNǑSTaW:g6R (W__S_NN TavMRc N NSNHh[tvQ[:gsQNXT؏SNbN-Nz,{ NNKNL [HhNۏL (WЏ(uTaW:g6R1Y%v`Q N Q[:gsQ؏SN͑/TQ[ z^ Seb` YQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6RvЏ\O0sSO[NrzNQ[:gsQvTaW:g6R TaW:g6RNQ[W:g6RKN[E N_NSu@wvNT~0(WLOSFU㉳QL?eNvǏ z-N S_NNKNYg:ONvcvla?a SNPRQ[W:g6R@bv 3u T{ Y 0 wɋ T{ 0ncNbcI{6R^Svl nSegOb[݋0ُNfTaW:g6RNQ[W:g6R(Wzz N/fN~(WNwv0 vQN NЏ\OǏ zeg w TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6RNv:N[ev gHeЏ\OcO/ec :NdkNHTsQvNOVvsQ|0Neb TaW:g6Rv gHeЏ\O NX[(WwQY[He'`vQ[W:g6R:NMRc0S g(WL?ev[NNeb gɋQ[W:g6RKNCg)Rv`Q N L?e:gsQNeMbSO:NNĉHhNۏeQ0RQ[W:g6RvΘi cSЏ(uTaW:g6R0Q[W:g6RvX[(W [E N:NL?ev[NcONNy$Ry{x0SY Q[:gsQNXTN-N\O:N-Nz,{ NNNeQTaW~~㉳QǏ z NSQ[:gsQ[NTOS@bۏLvNT[g _N/fnxOTa;mRj`[Tl'`Luv͑O01YSNQ[W:g6Rv NbON~_g\O(u TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R\eR gHeЏL ub1llv0~0SNeb Q[W:g6RRvS%c _Ny N_TaW:g6RvR0ُhs(WTaW:g6R:NQ[W:g6RۏLQvRKN N0(WHhNǏɋTaW:g6R_0RS㉄v`Q N dk{|~~1\SNMQNۏeQ0RQ[W:g6RKN-N N YQ{Q[W:g6Rvb O_TY\z:vDnMn0RfQ[W:g6RvHhNKN-N Q[:gsQVdkYf:NN[0WQHhN ُ gRN9eUЏ(uQ[W:g6R㉳Q~~vT(0sSO(W\ՋЏ(uTaW:g6RS㉠~~[JT1Y% HhNg~ۏeQ0RQ[W:g6Rv`Q N KNMR@b~SvTaW:g6R _NY(Ws^o`Se[b`~0mdS_NN NR[Evg0b_b:NS_NNKN@bqQ T TvN[W@x06e)NvVN&qpI{eb[T~Q[W:g6RvЏ(uS%cQ\O(u0 1udkS TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6RNQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6R/fv^X[NNVvL?eN㉳QSO|KN-Nv NUONe N1y[e USrX[(W0ُ_N1\ʑN:NNHN=\{1989t^6R[v 0L?eɋl 0feybkL?eɋ FOdk{|TaW~~㉳Q;mRN[ NN6q'Yϑ0W(WU^TЏL0ُyN~qQuvsQ|_Nhf \TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R[eQ0RL?eN㉳QWKN-N v^ N_6qOOQ[WL?eN㉳Q:g6Rv0WMOT\O(u0sSOTaW:g6R(WL?eN㉳Q[-N_0RhQbЏ(u Q[W:g6RN\(WN N$N*Neb~~S%cQ\O(uN/f(WS_NNKNelb gHeTaKNe \OQ~@\'`ve0N{|u;mvyr((WN _Y~~9h iNS_NNKN9h,g[zvNyO3z[SRXRN*NSv6R^ y0 Te ُyeWvL?eN㉳Q:g6Rv[eQ [NmQL?e:gsQNL?ev[NKNv[z`~NSV YL?ey^vTs^r`_NgwQs[aIN0(WhQbcۏOllVvS_ N N6qw[_TaWL?eN㉳Q:g6R Se.s zQRu. 0L?eɋl 0O9evW,geT  N 0L?eɋl 0,{1ag:N-N_ [J]. ς]'Yf[f[bTf[>yOyf[Hr , 2012, (1). s! . ĉR0TaNlt  L?eǏ z-NADR(uvS'`NYS_'`xvz [J]. lFUxvz, 2003, (5). YOQ. yl~~㉳Q!j_(WL?el NvЏ(u  fN'`~~㉳QADR KNtSW0YS_'`SvQq_T [J]. llxvz, 2007, (4). [e]ho][Ė. ~~v㉳QN[$R6R^ [M]. sNe, ы. SN: -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y, 1994. Genevra Richardson, Hazel Genn. Tribunals in Transition: Resolution or Adjudication? [J]. Public Law, 2007. Patricia M. Wald et al.. Use of Alternative Dispute Resolution: Better Ways to Resolve Some Public Sector Controversies [J]. Administrative Law Journal, 1987, (1). Carolyn Hay, Katharine Mckenna, Trevor Buck. Evaluation of Early Neutral Evaluation Alternative Dispute Resolution in the Social Security and Child Support Tribunal [R]. MOJ Research Series 2/10, 2010. John Hardin Young. Private Perspective on ADR in Federal Contract Disputes [C] // Marshall J. Breger (ed.), Federal Administrative Dispute Resolution Deskbook. Chicago: American Bar Association, 2001. Cynthia B. Dauber. The Ties that Do Not Bind: Nonbinding Arbitration in Federal Administrative Agencies [J]. Administrative Law Journal of American University, 1995, (9). s܀O. gؚNllb]\ObJT  2010t^3g11e(W,{ASNJ\hQVNlNh'YO,{ N!kO N [R]. gؚNllblQb, 2010, (4). s܀O. gؚNllb]\ObJT  2012t^3g11e(W,{ASNJ\hQVNlNh'YO,{N!kO N [R]. gؚNllblQb, 2012, (4). William F. Smith. Alternative Means of Dispute Resolution: Practices and Possibilities in the Federal Government [J]. Missouri Journal of Dispute Resolution, 1984. Lawrence E. Susskind, Sarah McKearnan. The Evolution of Public Policy Dispute Resolution [J]. Journal of Architectural and Planning Research, 2007, (16). Maurice Sunkin. Withdrawing: A Problem in Judicial Review? [C] // Peter Leyland and Terry Woods (eds.). Administrative Law Facing the Future: Old Constrains & New Horizons. London: Blackstone Press Limited, 1997. R. (on the application of Cowl) v Plymouth City Council, 1 W. L. R. 803 (2002). [_]Thomas Wrtenberger. _VL?eɋlKNeSU\ [J]. R^[, ы. Vz-Nck'Yf[lf[Ɩ R, 2009, (1). Hel. T:N5  L?eOSvl6R9ei [J]. L?elf[xvz, 2007, (3). [e]\e]IQΐ. L?eɋvg Rg [M]. s)YNS, ы. SN: -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y, 2014. []1g" _̑f. T\OltNeL?el [M]. k*mwm, HhQ, ы. SN: FURpSfN, 2010. Sophie Boyron. Mediation in Administrative Law: the Identification of Conflicting Paradigms [J]. European Public Law 2007, (13). Wolfgang Hoffmann-Riem, Irene Lamb. Negotiation and Mediation in the Public Sector: the German Experience [J]. Public Administration, 1994, (72). [k]lKQ" " KQ. l_vlKN~ [M]. Y[VN, ы. SN: l_QHr>y, 2008. Sophie Boyon. The Rise of Mediation in Administrative Law Disputes: Experiences from England, France and Germany [J]. Public Law, 2006. _eR. L?eɋT㉄vckS_'`VXSvQS [J]. lFUxvz, 2010, (5). Susan L. Carpenter, W.J.D. Kennedy. Managing Public Disputes: A Practical Guide for Government, Business, and Citizen s Group [M]. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2001. The Law Commission. Administrative Redress: Public Bodies and the Citizen: A Consultation Paper [R]. The Law Commission Consultation Paper No. 187, 2008. The Office of the Chairman of Administrative Conference of the United States. An Overview of Federal Agency Use of Alternative Means of Dispute Resolution [J]. Administrative Law Journal, 1987, (1). Philip J. Harter. Neither Cop nor Collection Agent: Encouraging Administrative Settlements by Ensuring Mediator Confidentiality [J]. Administrative Law Review, 1989, (41). Brett A. Williams. Consensual Approaches to Resolving Public Policy Disputes [J]. Journal of Dispute Resolution, 2000. c[kSN. lly^v^g [M]. SN: -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y, 1999. Harry T. Edwards. Alternative Dispute Resolution: Panacea or Anathema? [J]. Harvard Law Review, 1986, (99). []F׋y, 2001. [_]S+Y" Q" 6g. :NCg)R eN[M]. ဝ[wm, ы. SN: -NVl6RQHr>y, 2004. ( ez h1987 7u Ym_l~tQN ς]'Yf[sePlf[b^ lf[ZSX0,geShN 0l6RN>yOSU\ 02015t^,{4g v^N'Y YpSDe 0ɋlf[0Sl6R^ 02015t^,{11ghQel}0(W,geQ\OǏ z-N YOQNYec0UOwmlYec0qeYec0[NS3tYec0NgNI{^SfN N Tb__cOǏ.^R (Wdk("_  2009t^2011t^ hQVlbt^GWSt12.86NNN[L?eHhN hQVL?e Y:gsQt^GWSt9.13NN YHhN0ُN TeghQVt^GW400N600NNǏOYtvL?eNHhNpeϑ]ݍu܏0 NL?e YTL?eɋvpenc egnN2010t^2012t^v 0-NVl_t^t 00OpencQgؚNllbL?eoR^s/c[[ZSO@bb2vOo` SY[~N 0 lJT[ OHhNt^400NN 0 0NNSeb 02014t^11g5e ,{3Hr0 NV:NO [xvz>f:y (WSɋSl[g z^vL?eNHhN-N Ǐ95%vHhN/fǏNS_NN(WɋMRbɋ-Nvl0OSFURN㉳Qv0See Varda Bondy et al., Mediation and Judicial Review: An Empirical Research Study, The Public Law Project, 2009, p.19. bVf[YN T b OSFU egcyLOSFU:g6R0,ge NǑ(uُycl t1u gN,{N N͋'` N w  T N͋O͑Nh~~㉳Qv~g /f T͋ LOSFUhv/f~~㉳QvǏ z |R͋01uN0,{ Neċ0OI{TaW:g6Rh_v/f~~㉳QvǏ z ǑSLOSFUvclSNN[NOcN0,{N  L N͋p_>fNTaW:g6Rl g-Nz,{ NNE\Tvyr'` ُSN\vQN-Nz,{ NNObvOSFU;mR:S+R_eg0 2012t^4g10eS^v 0gؚNllbsQNib'YɋN^ɋvTcvwv~~㉳Q:g6R9eiՋp;`SOeHh 0fnxcQN(WlFUN~~W-N^z-Nzċ0O:g6RvBl0 ddkKNY -NVL?elf[Lu؏fgN lQCgR NSYRt \O:N(WL?eN㉳QWceЏ(uTaW:g6Rvt1u0FOZfяvxvz]~{_^seNWNtv(u0vsQxvz SSNg3t0=Nl_ 0L?eɋSN(u㉟SR 0 0l6RN>yOSU\ 02000t^,{4g ,{86-88usRe 0L?e Y㉄vckS_'`S6R^^g 0 0l6RN>yOSU\ 02013t^,{4g ,{146-148u0,ge[ُN NQU\_0 VYf[vvsQ SSLawrence Susskind and Jeffrey Cruikshank, Breaking the Impasse: Consensual Approaches to Resolve Public Disputes, Basic Books, 1987, pp.93-135; Lawrence Susskind and Denise Madigan,  New Approaches to Resolving Disputes in the Public Sector , Justice System Journal 9 (1984), pp.184-187. 2010t^Ǐv 0Nll 0T2012t^OTv 0lNɋl 0[Slnx6R^\OQNĉ[0 2014t^10g28elQ^v 0-NqQ-N.YsQNhQbcۏOllVr^͑'YvQ[ 0cQ ePhQ>yOwv~~2S:g6R [U0N0L?eQ0L?e Y0ɋI{ g:gTc0vNOSvYCQS~~㉳Q:g6R0 (W_e-N RechtN͋|QwQ l T Cg)R v+TIN0Vdk N_6g@bv lOVNeN ve T7h(uNCg)R06g,gN_NfnxbNُNp0S[_]S+YQ6g 0:NCg)R eN 0 ဝ[wmы -NVl6RQHr>y2004t^Hr ,{4-5u0     PAGE 12 y k 6R :g ~ ĸʸҸڸ68ܹƿƳ|rh^TJ@hm#hY,aJo(hm#haJo(hm#hc9aJo(hm#h[aJo(hm#hJ<aJo(hm#h4aJo(hm#hjyaJo(jhm#h0JUaJ haJo( hIaJo( h*aJo(h0JaJo(hhH*aJo( h7HaJo(h*h*aJo(hh':5OJQJaJo(hha 5OJQJaJo(hh45OJQJaJo("&@DLVZ\`lntx|ĺкܺ>BFHR^bƼеЫ|r|rk h*aJo(hm#haJo(hm#h<aJo(hm#haJo(hm#hB*aJo(phhMqGB*aJo(phhm#h20aJo( hUfaJo(hm#haJo(hm#haJo( haJo(hm#h.aJo(hm#hc9aJo(hm#hlsaJo(hm#hjyaJo('bhpv|ĻȻʻλлڻ <>ټټ̸¸̸̮̮̥̮̮̮̮ݮm#(m#(m#(m#Ѱm#(m#20(m#<aJo(hm#hM\RaJo( haJo(hm#haJo(hm#haJo( h*aJo( hIaJo(2ļȼҼܼ *.248:>DLRrxνҽԽؽܽDPrƼ| hfaJo( hIaJo(hm#ho:aJo(hm#hBaJo(hm#h( aJo(hm#hNaJo(hm#hZ(aJo(hm#haJo(hm#h.aJo(hm#haJo(hm#haJo( haJo(hm#hx}yaJo(hm#hY,aJo(-rz~ľƾʾоҾ 4LNRVdfͼͼᡗ|rhhm#haJo(hm#haJo(hm#h~aJo(hm#haJo( hg8aJo(hm#haJo(hm#h;raJo( hPnaJo(hm#h.aJo(hm#hx}yaJo( hfaJo(hm#hFaJo(hm#ho:aJo(hm#h( aJo(hm#h>baaJo(hm#hsOaJo(#fhjxܿ $&<Plnz|ָ֮֐xndd]] h"BaJo(hm#hPnaJo(hm#h`{paJo( hERaJo(hm#hB'aJo( hPnaJo(hm#hJlaJo(hm#heu;aJo(hm#helaJo(hm#h/ waJo(hm#h>vaJo(hm#hZaJo(hm#hsOaJo(hm#hOGCaJo(hh|o5OJQJaJo(hhu5OJQJaJo($&(,2>&(.2:JNR^`dhrv~$,02ùwk\khm#h,gB*aJo(phhtXB*aJo(phh& B*aJo(ph htXaJo(hm#h%ZdaJo(hm#hWaJo(hm#haJo(hm#h.Z0aJo( h&yaJo(hm#heu;aJo(hm#hJlaJo( h6uaJo( hNQaJo(hx&hx&aJo( h& aJo(jhPn0JUaJ hPnaJo(#2<V^fhx|~*:VZbʾʾʾ律sdTh\>hh5CJOJPJo(h\>h g5CJOJPJo( (2FHZ`°џ}}llZlZI h]MhpB*CJaJo(ph#h]Mhp5B*CJaJo(ph h]Mh1fB*CJaJo(ph h]MhNB*CJaJo(ph h]Mh6 B*CJaJo(ph h]MhQB*CJaJo(ph#h]MhQ5B*CJaJo(phh]Mh1fB*aJo(ph#h]Mh1f5B*CJaJo(ph7jh]MhN"5B*CJUaJmHnHo(phuNEE $IfgdL@kd$$IfTl    Fw   t0    6    44 lapyt]MT $$Ifa$gd]M 2:FZNEE $IfgdL@ $$Ifa$gd]Mkd$$IfTl    eFw   t0    6    44 lapyt]MTFHZnZNEE $IfgdL@ $$Ifa$gd]Mkdd$$IfTl    #Fw   t0    6    44 lapyt]MT`hnpvz~ϽyhYyhH7 h]MhNB*CJaJo(ph h]MhQB*CJaJo(phh]Mh1fB*aJo(ph h]Mh1fB*CJaJo(ph#h]Mh1f5B*CJaJo(ph#h]MhQ5B*CJaJo(phh]Mh`B*aJo(ph h]Mh`B*CJaJo(ph#h]Mh`5B*CJaJo(phh]MhpB*aJo(ph h]MhpB*CJaJo(ph h]Mh~B*CJaJo(phZNEE $IfgdL@ $$Ifa$gd]Mkd$$IfTl    #Fw   t0    6    44 lapyt]MTZNEE $IfgdL@ $$Ifa$gd]Mkd$$IfTl    #Fw   t0    6    44 lapyt]MTZNEE $IfgdL@ $$Ifa$gd]Mkdz$$IfTl    #Fw   t0    6    44 lapyt]MTBD(4@DHxl`lYOHOA hv8yaJo( hmaJo(h_h_aJo( h_aJo(hvB*aJo(phh_B*aJo(phhB*aJo(phhSKB*aJo(phhmB*aJo(phh1MB*aJo(phh WB*aJo(phh6 B*aJo(phhvhvB*aJo(phh]Mh1fB*aJo(ph h]MhQB*CJaJo(ph h]Mh1fB*CJaJo(ph,ZQQFQFF WD`gdL@`gdL@kd,$$IfTl    2Fw   t0    6    44 lapyt]MTHTVbd DF",BDH"䲦sh=B*aJo(phh&rB*aJo(phhhB*aJo(phhB*aJo(phhB*aJo(phh_h_B*aJo(ph hmaJo( h7aJo( hSKaJo( haJo( h+<aJo(h_h_aJo( hv8yaJo(h_hv8yaJo()"&(.2@D\^f ,4:PZٵ͚͚vvj^^ha^QB*aJo(phh_(B*aJo(phh7B*aJo(phh+<B*aJo(phh+^B*aJo(phh]hB*aJo(phh0rB*aJo(phhB*aJo(phh]B*aJo(phhEB*aJo(phhhB*aJo(phh&rB*aJo(phh,OB*aJo(ph$(,4HJT|4:Fh*JNƿƸƸƿƩymamamah#pB*aJo(phh B*aJo(phh7B*aJo(phh)B*aJo(phh1MB*aJo(phhB*aJo(phha^Qh1fB*aJo(ph h+^aJo( h+<aJo(ha^Qha^QaJo(ha^QB*aJo(phh]B*aJo(phh+<B*aJo(phhEB*aJo(ph!&((HV`bxzܸܩ|u|n`U`Uh YOJQJaJo(h Yh YOJQJaJo( h!aJo( hC,,aJo(hC,,hC,,H*aJo( hkaJo(hbbhbbaJ hbbaJo(h Yh YaJo(h YhEB*aJo(phh YB*aJo(phh,B*aJo(phh#pB*aJo(phhEB*aJo(phh DB*aJo(phh@NB*aJo(ph!  *.(.4PVbf  $(*񸢔止梉ۢ~ۉ~h=OJQJaJo(h_OJQJaJo(h Yh DOJQJaJo(hGOJQJaJo(h DOJQJaJo(hVNOJQJaJo(h Yh YaJjh Yh Y0JUaJh!OJQJaJo(h3OJQJaJo(h Yh YOJQJaJo(,*,0246HJ\^`dtxz~tettVtF9FhBGLB*H*aJo(phhC,,hC,,B*H*aJo(phhChhChB*aJo(phhChhGB*aJo(phhChhwMB*aJo(phhChh=B*aJo(phhChh:NB*aJo(phh\>w5Cʴ(\>hJ5CJOJPJo(h\>h&mT5CJOJPJo(h\>h5CJOJPJo(h YhB*aJo(ph,Jrr$z dN* & F 7hh^h`gdIgdc`gdL@$88@&XDdYDda$gdL@,.246:>@DFJLNTVZ^vzǸǸǘzkzzkzkkhChhsbB*aJo(phhChhQ&B*aJo(phhChhNuB*aJo(ph&jhChhNu0JB*UaJphh=B*aJo(phhChh~B*aJo(phhChhY}B*aJo(phhChhwMB*aJo(phhChhyB*aJo(phh!B*aJo(ph$(>Z`f:BTXlĽ}n^RIRhb2+CJaJo(hIhICJaJo(hchc5B*aJo(phhchERB*aJo(phh)B*aJo(ph h$aJo( h!aJo( hyaJo( hChaJo( hsbaJo( haaJo(hm#hsbaJo( h7aJo(hChhGB*aJo(phhChhsbB*aJo(phhChhY}B*aJo(phhChhChB*aJo(ph ".0\djlprx|DFPX\djlprпyhIB*CJaJo(phheyB*CJaJo(phhcB*CJaJo(phh|B*CJaJo(phhb2+B*CJaJo(ph hIhIB*CJaJo(ph hIhcB*CJaJo(phh|CJaJo(hIhICJaJo(hb2+CJaJo(/28:LPRlnǹxgg[R[FR[hCshICJaJo(hCsCJaJo(hIhICJaJo( hCshIB*CJaJo(ph#hCshIB*CJ\aJo(phhCshIB*CJaJph hCshIB*CJ\aJphhIhIB*CJaJphhCsB*CJaJo(phhCsB*CJaJphhIB*CJaJo(phhb2+B*CJaJo(ph hIhIB*CJaJo(ph:>TVFP`&4bd "$FH8:>JNdlxzʼʼʼʰʼʼʼʼʼʼʼʖʁhH2B*CJaJphhH2CJaJo(hIhH2CJaJo(h)B*CJaJo(phh)B*CJaJphhH2B*CJaJo(phh)h)B*CJaJph h)hIB*CJaJo(phhIhICJaJo(hCsCJaJo(,z hjt~02ť|ŋhH2hH2B*CJaJphhH2B*CJaJphhH2B*CJaJo(phh)h)B*CJaJph h)hlm B*CJaJo(phh)B*CJaJo(phh|B*CJaJo(phhlm B*CJaJo(ph h)h)B*CJaJo(ph. 68rpr`bd|ȹȪqcUcqcqcqh|B*CJaJo(phh(nYB*CJaJo(ph h0oh0oB*CJaJo(phhZ2B*CJaJo(phhtB*CJaJo(phh{DB*CJaJphh0oh0oB*CJaJphhZ2hZ2B*CJaJphh)B*CJaJo(phhqI:B*CJaJphhqI:B*CJaJo(phhqI:hqI:B*CJaJph!(48@FHLN^bt&(*DFǾǾǾǾǾᰑᰑthqI:B*CJaJo(phh4h4B*CJaJphh)B*CJaJo(ph h0oh)B*CJaJo(phh|B*CJaJo(phh|CJaJo(h0oh0oCJaJo(h0oB*CJaJo(ph h0oh0oB*CJaJo(phh(nYB*CJaJo(ph-  "&(*,X\pt"8@BDFJLNPdhvլպպ՞h|B*CJaJo(ph h4h4B*CJaJo(phh)B*CJaJo(phh4B*CJaJo(phh4hqI:B*CJaJphhqI:B*CJaJphhqI:B*CJaJo(phh4h4B*CJaJphh{DB*CJaJo(ph2*,Ph*pN<LWD^`LgdLWD^`LgdfVLWD^`LgdPgd"l & F 7hh^h`gdIBDbd"fh&02˺˒}rfrfrfr}}}hqI:hCJaJo(hqI:hCJaJhhCJaJo(hqI:CJaJo(hhCJaJh4h4B*CJaJphh|B*CJaJo(ph h4h4B*CJaJo(phh4B*CJaJo(phhqI:B*CJaJphhqI:B*CJaJo(phh4B*CJaJph(468 "$&(*JLfl(24>PTX`jrtvx|¹¹ڭڭڜp¹¹aaahhnUB*CJaJphhhIB*CJaJphhnUB*CJaJo(phhhB*CJaJph hh4B*CJaJo(phhhqI:CJaJo(hnUCJaJo(hIhnUCJaJo(hqI:hCJaJo(hqI:CJaJo(hhCJaJo( hhB*CJaJo(ph&|$&(:DJVnpvzJTV^dhlt~ѷ÷÷ѩѩѩѩÚÚ÷ÚËÚvh|CJaJo(hC,,hC,,CJaJo(hC,,h(^B*CJaJphhC,,hC,,B*CJaJphh|B*CJaJo(phh(^B*CJaJphh(^B*CJaJo(ph hhB*CJaJo(phh4B*CJaJo(phhhB*CJaJph,$0>BJLNd~rп|oeoeXhhPB*o(phhPB*o(phh{?NhPB*o(phh+hPo( hPo( j*hPhP0Jh"lB*CJaJo(phh4B*CJaJo(phh\WDB*CJaJo(ph hC,,hC,,B*CJaJo(ph hC,,h4B*CJaJo(phhC,,hC,,CJaJo(h|CJaJo(h\WDCJaJo("bdfhlpvx"*.6 (>PºɤhshCs6 haMPhCs h~waJo(h/n hCsaJo( hCsaJo( h*Io( h~wo( hCso(h0hCso( h0hCsjh& hCs0JH*UhPhPB*o(phh~hPB*o(ph hPo(h4hPo(2"2:<>Nn 04Nƹ˱饘h7hCs6o(h0}hCso( hHhCs h$o(hHhCso( ho( h phCsh phCso(h8hCso( h9NWo( hEo(jh& hCs0JH*Uhw#hCso( haMPhCs hCso(hshCs6hshCs6o(.N\,.8<LN "JPRdHJLN<>@DF货胴{wowojhUhhZhCso(hOqhCso(hj7hCso(hNQB*o(phhmB*o(phhD)hCsB*o(phjh& hCs0JH*Uh-rhCs6o(h-rhCs6hL|hCso(hCs h{(hCs hCso(h7hCs6o(h7hCs6+ L<>BDHJNPTVnprtxz~G$gdN" &`#$gdxYD2gd+,xYD2gdH2LWD^`LgdfVFJLPRVXdfjlnrtvxz|~ǺǺǺǺǺǺǺh"lB*CJaJo(phhN"hCs5B*phhN"hCs5B*o(phhCshP0JmHnHu hCs0JjhCs0JUjhUh$gd"lG$gdN" =182P:pt<0@P. A!"#$%S $$If!vh#v #v :V l t0    6,5 5 pyt]MT$$If!vh#v #v :V le t0    6,5 5 pyt]MT$$If!vh#v #v :V l# t0    6,5 5 pyt]MT$$If!vh#v #v :V l# t0    6,5 5 pyt]MT$$If!vh#v #v :V l# t0    6,5 5 pyt]MT$$If!vh#v #v :V l# t0    6,5 5 pyt]MT$$If!vh#v #v :V l2 t0    6,5 5 pyt]MTb 2 0@P`p2( 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p8XV~PJ_HmH nHsH tHJ`J cke $1$a$ CJKH_HaJmH nHsH tH\@2\ }h 3$dd1$@&[$\$a$5CJKHOJQJ\^JaJ$A`$ ؞k=W[SOBi@B nfh*ph('`a( uybl_(uCJaJ*@r* uybleW[$a$*j@qr* uybl;N5\.@. uyblFhe,gCJaJN@N M<-u w'$ 9r &dG$Pa$CJaJ8Y8 ~ech~gV-D M "W`" 6p5\ff 1fQxjm)ʬuWLfdݮ+5_4csj-V?k3rm}gz gs嚋7xwsȈR W*)|jȫKXͫ dXIBF؇bnh ( *'vɗ3KZjz'c*_=}<9ݻw~]8^~_o?xYýg~^G}J0Emh=Ԅ Ξa>s$-, Oɠ=Hp Ua/ UO d*:(.fTU/!9$V[|hrvs-iUt. 6ڪ4Cebs)bMjBekp um,fd$͑{6GUVf~b#Vb@qTTW.ޛd)i@vdq9Y^X7{2%uHx+af6]>f#*qqDᵁ)@?71oggo`:fղekp£2֌Nj8ǰD CB?81e>Է]16褣֧ 9& e w(,68DNn-C5eCF DN DN$b \v  > | z~4>r:"x%h(),.&0042d47Z9:;V=h>A BhCDGtKMDQQSZUVbrf2`H"*z|NF,./0123456789:;<>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSUVWXYZ[dHF,*-=T !@  @H 0(   @(  bB  3 $__TH_L16"?  X__TH_B1117"?   X__TH_B1218"?   X__TH_B1319"?   X__TH_B1420"?   X__TH_B2121"?   X__TH_B2222"?   X__TH_B2323"? B S  ?4/5/6/7/8/9/:/;/DN95t.7*>t# t&#t41tB^>etPLtt0p0p0p0p0p0p 0p!0p"0p#0p$0p%0p&0p'0p(0p)0p*0p+0p,0p-0p.0p;;<<===>>>>-@-@"C+C6C6CDDEEEN     ;;<<===>>>>3@3@)C1C=C=CDD E EEN =*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PlaceType=*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PlaceNameB*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagscountry-region9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace8*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCity9 *urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsState;*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsaddress:*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsStreet  /02@A[]no9c(k g +SUWYZ[lTUVm hQRy 13OwOPl1 2 !!!!""$$*$$$G'-(:(;(<(B(C(\(f(((())C*O+++-r--..../ /!/V/Z/[/r/s///////////////////////////S0T0000011G445556T7U7Z777888_9a9f9g9j9l9999999999::-:.:E:H:J:K:M:O:Q:Z:b:i:|::;;<<<<======->5>? ???@@@@@@@@@@A AAA3A6A8A9A;A=A?AHAQARASAYAjAmAoArAtAuAwAyA{AAAABBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBqCuCDD?G@GAGDGFG]GbGdGGGGGGGGGGG,HeHfHIIIIIJJJJJ;MMMMMMMMMMNNNNNNNNNNN)N,N-NBNENpr #HJcf  qrPT=@(-EG m"p"###$%$$$%!%%%& &))**,,,,f-h-!.#.0011.111U1X1]1`111(2+2b2c2.313;3>3W3Z33344 55H5J555556666Z8\8d8j88899990:1:::??oArABBUCXCbGcGlGmGGGGGGfJiJJJ?KBKiKjK,M.MNNNNNNNNN,N-NGKKM,-.0134679:CI_-pEQ v$9]ELOVY2V'A+Gbi'?A{DIRUVs."06Q`ch_R +*mty+/3OPlo t~5.6ERVW]flrxYZ"lP!`lxEJ(_D 9O \| | {!v-!Ti!5"E"N"KR"\"7&# 5#H#L#]#m#n#)r#x#|#$[ $W$$7$ B$pW$8%fE%Q%3l%&'?&Q&_&b&'$'u@'B' _'v'x'W((h#(A(Z(_(1a(p()7)=)D)`)m}))**]K*P*++ +.+b2+a+d+e+k ,J,,*,+,C,,G,K,KV,Y,_u,/-{ --d8-M<-a-l-v .q.?.@.W./(/E/aO/CW/[/i/v/00'0!0<+020D0.Z0Qh0q0wt0)191wJ1J1O1`1X22'E2H2CI2Z2\2]2`2b2h2<H<J<L<"=91=U=W=\=)z=C>>0>->#>[>\>]>>>UItInJ0Jr J}K3KSKK$K*Kq+K1DKQKpKLLp3LBGL:HL\KLTLbL MM!M)M]McMKjMwMwM~M:NNN{?N@NHNKNmNtN{NFO O0 O\ O,Ok@O&EO P P$Pk%P1PjPkQlQ'Q 0Q@QNQa^QcQRR !RQURM\RwRzRDSSWS_\SiSnS$TT^TNTA*T.T=TFTXT)kT&mTnUV UX UGBUNUPUNXUUR/Vq8VV=VFVfVkVJW Wi WWKW9NWOWVWaWdW hW %X8X8MXRXdXkXyX_YQY(nY%ZZWZ+Zs#Zi$ZfZxZxZV[u[[([#8[q[\\ \\8\U\X\]-]ZD]d] ^^^V$^+^L.^P^~^(_!-_4_<_K_^_yj_m_@x_`x5`?` Y`|k`z`aaOaTaea"aL+aB1aU2a:5a?a>bajasasabR4bN5bTbbbcbVlbsb}bcY5c>cNc^ckcd,d2dWd%Zd_dvdVeeEeRe[efeUf.f6fE;fHfQJfZfrfgg g,gf1g67g=g~ghr hWh+hBhChGh?Lh)Uh\h\h8]hP~h> iiib i&FiTi`ini; j&j'jj/j*Pj_jqjyjh k7#kSKkfk=nktkQ6lel1ll&vl'm"m.mFMmQm n*9nq>n!Fn=JnPn ]n o"o0o;ov|Dv_Ovc`vdvv w/ w,w~*nJ5tzD.9DSVT]FdgFGv X+Ofpurp}7 7z$[EO8~nx&'+<o=Ic pz3\>+imv{&),)-19Ϸɐ>;/ՑĴǑ.?<>HQCRX[&ir}4Fi_cec0m '8IjOg1NIOOSTTfhnxPy1 4!*0D5q~R;[ %I\`6A[go:o"#+.)ZZ pYH{ 9<dfEgri+m]OM`,UtX])M4F1fml]anx A '0J.z= #[.w7jBE2P~g68D:;SrYp^elr$N~&D@ jnV~,:tq#''3HPVXpO4_XQcekqG%b&+0B3G<[y"*D2*^F ;(^`goteu~!j*]Nuzzr|$!+>CwUb+fpE ~%A1C#!,7P?wM[rit/~{&ANTYaw#/Q7U=eEK8LGoqTr'-2EG]Y;Ot!'-LGj@ 00X<NP]orf~ao8;?J}W {9Oafz-|R((35;_ye|oz{|2(t1AJR]n~ ?]tyT G/R@%HJ6uuYyd'P8mqsvThi7x)H?+HI||F.=uW\g u,LQY.MO58U/!+<JMdim '=6Dnns/3Tofk u{(@:TT%Uj8 I7 ?sORh|-/5@jU\k^45,9x$S`lu)|4Azz3rx)\=szwUF r_| uLov; <CDz: `5J^`lks_wY0*AnS)U)z4Yk|4ri~ /QV]'pz&$)2@Cg(:1XEVabkw<BpD^GJgjGd)o3|5$6@gjL 8 Yf)V+cW\w}cOTwYZ^ )6W\}fEk]K]Cv$K<>DZ?b!%3&([d! KzW@= [} $^JXbmk+n a V$Q]a&-=rBLoeyyy !|:Zx/W\Hk#pxJy*T Ye_ * !M%.h:/>Xy\dqjs: l "<auJO7=K9kTk!;\mv?| )-VN\_m'e15:GHLZR8ScikDoz~ -9 PVwiy#*EJvLdyu$&,.q6D8OXr(`asd< bsg !N2}:=8Cbseh.%$2Eh8mxM~0% DJQfn3<G)1MiSU^i0rsg)*13|`4fPlw &7LLPrZ ~BK $+B+Pm v !y49euvR7HIP6VY&6|hGN_Fjq~*$Stm -Y2.GMM_o0rt 7HLP_]pmqGG@L'DN   ( 4 > UnknownG*Ax Times New Roman5Symbol3. *Cx Arial;([SOSimSunA5  wiSO_GB2312wiSOA$BCambria Math 1h ,IO = $ }B '-!),.:;?]}    & 6"0000 0 0 00000 =@\]^([{  0 0 00000;[2GM8< 3qHX?v2!xx ezOo`sldsld$      Oh+'0l  ( 4 @LT\d Ϣsld Normal.dotmsld243Microsoft Office Word@< @N?@(  =՜.+,0 X`t|  Microsoft$G   !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry F@qData 1TablejWordDocument ?bSummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8MsoDataStoreТpuTXDG1AOOC==2ТpuItem  PropertiesUCompObj n   FMicrosoft Word 97-2003 ĵ MSWordDocWord.Document.89q